Jason Oppenheim, the real estate executive featured prominently on Netflix's reality series Selling Sunset, has developed a reputation for maintaining professional relationships with former romantic partners. Throughout his tenure in the public eye, Oppenheim has navigated several high-profile relationships, many of which have involved colleagues from his real estate firm, The Oppenheim Group.
The pattern of workplace romance began years before cameras started rolling. According to statements from cast member Amanza Smith, Oppenheim's relationship history within his professional sphere extends back over a decade. This intersection of personal and professional life has become a defining characteristic of the reality series, which premiered in 2019.
Early Relationships and Professional Dynamics
Nicole Young, who joined the Selling Sunset cast during its sixth season in May 2023, represents one of Oppenheim's earliest known relationships within his professional network. The pair dated approximately ten years prior to Young's television debut. Smith confirmed this timeline in August 2022, noting that Young was among the first of Oppenheim's colleagues with whom he pursued a romantic relationship.
Mary Fitzgerald, another prominent cast member, dated Oppenheim for approximately one year in 2014. During the series' first season, Fitzgerald discussed the relationship's gradual dissolution, revealing that the couple had lived together and experienced what she described as a "lingering kind of period" before ultimately separating. Despite the romantic conclusion, both have maintained their professional association and appear regularly together on the program.
High-Profile Romance and Its Conclusion
Oppenheim's relationship with Chrishell Stause garnered significant media attention when the pair confirmed their romance in July 2021. The relationship developed from an existing friendship and working relationship, following the pattern established in Oppenheim's previous partnerships. However, the romance proved short-lived, concluding by December of the same year.
Stause addressed the separation publicly, attributing the split to fundamental differences regarding family planning. In a statement shared via social media, she emphasized that Oppenheim's position on having children ultimately proved incompatible with her own desires. Nevertheless, Stause characterized the relationship's end as amicable, stating that their mutual respect and affection would continue despite the romantic conclusion. Stause subsequently married musician G Flip in May 2023.
Relationships Beyond the Workplace
Oppenheim has also pursued relationships outside his immediate professional circle. In July 2022, he was photographed with model Marie-Lou Nurk in Mykonos, Greece, confirming a new romantic involvement. The relationship lasted less than one year, with both parties announcing their separation in May 2023 through a joint statement.
The statement cited geographical distance as the primary obstacle to continuing the relationship. Both individuals expressed continued affection and friendship, maintaining that they would remain supportive of one another despite the romantic conclusion. This pattern of preserving friendships after romantic relationships end has become a consistent theme in Oppenheim's personal life.
Recent Developments
In April 2025, Oppenheim made his relationship with Jessica Vargas public by appearing together at the Los Angeles premiere of The Accountant 2. Vargas, a real estate agent employed by The Oppenheim Group, represents clients across multiple affluent areas including West Hollywood, Malibu, and Beverly Hills, according to her professional profile.
The relationship concluded in February 2026, with Oppenheim announcing the separation through social media. In keeping with his established pattern, he emphasized that the romantic aspect had ended while the friendship remained intact. Vargas echoed this sentiment, expressing hope that others might find similar amicable post-relationship dynamics.
Oppenheim's relationship history demonstrates a consistent approach to managing the intersection of personal and professional life. His ability to maintain working relationships with former romantic partners has allowed him to continue operating his real estate business while navigating the additional scrutiny that accompanies reality television fame. This pattern suggests a prioritization of professional stability and personal friendship over the potential complications that workplace romance might typically introduce.